National Association of Gay & Lesbian Real Estate Professionals

Lancaster Gay Realtor & Gay Real Estate

Keller Williams Greater Columbus Realty - Jay Mattlin

Average Rating

Contact: Jay Mattlin
Title: Realtor

Member Since 2020

Company Address
Keller Williams Greater Columbus Realty
603 W Wheeling St
Lancaster, Ohio
United States 43130

Cities Served
Buckeye Lake, Canal Winchester, Carroll, Junction City, Lancaster, Logan, Millersport, New Lexington, Pickerington, Somerset, Sugar Grove


Cell: (740) 974-4190

Pricing Strategy Adviser At Home with Diversity e-PRO C-RETS

Professional Achievements
Rookie Agent Award, Lancaster Bd of Realtors, 2016 Silver Sales Award, Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate, 2017 Bronze Sales Award, Lancaster Bd of Realtors, 2018, 2019

You loathe typical real estate agent bios. Don’t worry, I do too. They’re like cardboard — stiff, bland, and identical to every other bio out there. Instead of boasting ad nauseum about awards and accomplishments you’re not interested in, I’m taking the novel approach of actually giving you what you want — real answers to questions you’re probably wondering right now.

Will you return my calls and emails?

Yes. Without question. I realize this is one of the major frustrations the general public has with dealing with agents. I get dozens of calls and emails daily, and I work hard to reply as quickly as possible. My goal is typically within one business day.

I’ve met many Realtors who are jerks. Are you?

Depends on who you ask. If you ask certain agents who have stood between my clients and their real estate goals, they’ll probably say “yes”. A handful of people think I leave golden footprints in the sand. Those are the two extremes, and most people’s opinion falls somewhere in the middle. Here’s what I can tell you: I’m honest and candid. I take pride in being approachable and friendly. And if you need a quick real estate brain, or a strong dose of honesty, you’re in the right place. Loyalty to family, clients, and friends is one of my core values. Want to really find out if I’m a jerk? Mess with one of those people.

Do You Have experience doing exactly what I need?

Until you tell me what you need, there is no way of knowing. These are “strong suits” of mine: ● Working with new buyers ● First time sellers ● USDA / FHA ● Investment and Rental properties ● Property Management / Tenant Management If your goal or situation isn’t represented on that list, don’t worry. Contact me anyway. If I can’t help, I can get you referred to an another agent who can.

What kind of work are you really good at?

On a personal level, I’m pretty good at making wine. My pomegranate Zinfandel is amazing I’m told. I’m also pretty good at kayaking, hiking, and in general being outdoors. I’m also really good at giving back to my community because community and culture is important to me and our long term well being as a race. On a professional level, here are the skill-sets that I’ve developed over the years: ● Listening. Unfortunately, it’s a lost art these days. ● Detail oriented. I know everyone says this but I’m pretty obsessive and a bit of a perfectionist. ● Organized. This is so important in real estate. Even a little disorganization can ruin a deal.

Kellie S - Lancaster, OH: 2021-02-06

Jay was fantastic! We had spoken to a few other realtors before we worked with Jay. The other realtors were not punctual, and we lost out on opportunities because of it. Just days into our home search with Jay and we were in contract! He walked us through every step of home buying, and made sure we received updates. He helped explain our appraisal and inspections, and gave good advice every step of the way. It was a seamless, streamlined process. We felt like we could relax and trust him to handle it, unlike with the realtors we tried before. Honestly, cannot say enough good things about him! We will definitely recommend others to buy or sell their home with Jay! 🙂

Susie T - Lancaster, Ohio: 2020-12-03

Jay is very intelligent, friendly, and keeps an open line of communication from start to finish. His attention to detail is impeccable; he will proactively let you know of anything that’s easy to overlook, as he doesn’t want you to have any “surprises” that aren’t pleasant in the future. He treats you as an equal and a friend and is willing to explain the process of purchasing, always with patience and your best interest in mind. I would recommend him for anyone looking to purchase land or a home, regardless of if it’s your first or tenth purchase.

Dawn W - Cincinnati, OH: 2020-09-30

Jay was always prompt and courteous in communications. He spoke with clear intentions. I am grateful for his professional knowledge and expertise that helped make an already stressful situation enjoyable. Thank you

Lisa V - Lancaster, Ohio: 2020-06-30

Jay will ask you to do two things: Provide him with your pre-approval letter and tell him what you want most in a home. After that, you really don't have to do anything. I know that last statement is not entirely true, but it feels that way. He covers everything! He answers all of your questions. He takes fear and uncertainty out of the process. This allows you to relax and enjoy the entire experience. He gave me a book at the first showing: "The Ultimate Home Buyer's Guide", by Jay Mattlin. This became a valued reference guide. Bravo!! Take the time to read it, often. Jay is with you every step of the way. From the first showing to the last. Putting in an offer. Explaining every detail of the contract. Attending the home inspection. Negotiating a price reduction as a result of the home inspection. Providing a timeline for your reference during the process. When you are on this journey to purchase a home. You soon realize, you have a team: mortgage broker, insurance agent and your realtor. Jay is the team captain. Yesterday, this single woman became a homeowner. I could not have done that without Jay Mattlin. Lisa Virgin, Lancaster Ohio

Brandon P - Pleasantville, OH: 2020-06-19

Jay is an amazing realtor and paid very close attention to our wants and needs. He made sure that he found the perfect place for us and that we had everything we needed to for the process of buying a home. He found the perfect home for us and I could not be happier using him. Jay is an excellent person and will address any concerns or needs you have throughout the entire homebuying process!

Rebecca W - Lancaster, Ohio: 2020-02-27

Unfortunately the reason for selling our house is because of a marriage separation. As anyone can imagine this situation required some extra understanding and care. Jay was amazing throughout the process. He was organized and professional from the first contact. He was kind and patient when things got tense. Selling a house is difficult enough on its own. But I can’t imagine going through the situation with anyone but Jay. He was the very definition of rising above and beyond. I would never go with anyone else.

April W - Lancaster , OH: 2020-02-27

Jay made the selling process a breeze! Our family dynamic is unique (LGBTQ), and rare in this area. We knew that Jay would be sensitive to our needs. We appreciate Jay’s honesty and experience in the field, as well as his lifetime knowledge of the Lancaster area. He was reliable, responded quickly, and was open to any and all questions. We appreciate his accessibility, honesty, and sensitivity. We are so thankful for him!

Contact Jay Mattlin

error: Content is protected !!